This is my Beauty Refelctions Liquid Eyeliner, Maybellline One By One Volume Express, and Maybelline Eye Studio Gel Liner in Blackest Black, and the Brush the Gel Liner came with. The Beauty Reflections liner is a great dupe for the Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner at about $5 less of the price. The Mascara is one of my favorites although I’ll probably be on to a bigger and better one next month, or at least one that give me more length. Lol. I give the Gel Liner a 10/10. It doesn’t smudge, wear off, or dry out no matter what anyone says it’s lasted me about a year now and is still going strong!